When to legally dispute a total loss verdict

Published: 

March 4, 2026

The insurance industry is heavily regulated in Illinois. This gives both insurance providers and consumers rights and obligations for the protection of both. In the case of total loss in Illinois, an affected consumer has the right to question the decision of the insurance company to declare a total loss and can dispute this action if necessary. How do you know when you have the right to lodge a dispute? To answer that question, it is necessary to understand some of the key provisions of the Unfair Claim Settlement Practices Act of Illinois.

What Is The Unfair Claim Settlement Practices Act of Illinois?

Illinois’s advanced and far-reaching insurance code regulates the service that insurance companies offer to their clients. Each insurance provider has a legal obligation to handle their claims promptly, fairly and transparently. The code lists many actions on the part of insurance companies that can be considered improper claims practices. These include:

  • Knowingly misrepresenting relevant facts and policy provisions.
  • Engaging in activity that prompts a disproportionate number of legitimate complaints against the company.
  • Refusing to pay claims or knowingly underpaying them without proper investigations and without legitimate cause.
  • Attempting to settle claims on the basis of an application that was altered without notifying the claimant.
  • When denying a claim or offering a compromise settlement, failing to provide a reasonable and accurate explanation of the basis in the insurance policy or applicable law for denying or underpaying the claim.
  • Attempting to settle a claim for less than the amount to which the claimant is entitled under the policy, establishing unreasonable caps or limits on paint or material when estimating vehicle repairs, or neglecting to pay additional charges such as sales tax, title transfer fees, tag transfer fees and more when replacing or repairing a vehicle.

These are only some of the stipulations of the code. The Unfair Claim Settlement Practices Act means that all claimants have the right to take legal action against insurers who violate any part of the state’s insurance code. This applies in many different scenarios, including in those cases when the insurance company declares a total loss and replaces a vehicle or pays out a cash settlement, but pays less than the car was actually worth or refuses to pay for taxes and fees incurred when the replacement vehicle is purchased. This is a common complaint that consumers make against insurance companies and one that entitles claimants to seek compensation.

Our Illinois-based legal team can help you with any improper claims practices

If you were insured under an auto insurance policy, experienced a total loss car accident, and were not reimbursed for sales tax and other fees by your insurance company in the last 5 years, you may qualify to join a total loss car accident class action lawsuit investigation. ContactShamis & Gentile and book a free consultation. One of our experienced total loss lawyers will gladly assess the details of your claim and help you take action against the insurance company.

Contributors
Full name
Job title, Company name
Full name
Job title, Company name
Full name
Job title, Company name
Don’t Miss the Cases That Matter
Get free alerts about active cases, cash you can claim in lawsuits, data breaches, hidden fees, and other investigations that could affect you.

Join thousands of others to receive updates today.
Email Address
We respect your privacy and keep all information confidential.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Client Reviews and Testimonials

I absolutely love Shamis & Gentile! The attorneys' attentiveness is remarkable, making me feel valued as a client. Their expertise and clear communication set them apart. The pay close attention to detail and ensure they follow up with clients. I highly recommend Shamis & Gentile for anyone in need of outstanding legal representation.

Monica De Armas

Andrew was extremely personable, timely with responding and keeping me abreast with the status of my case. I would highly recommend this firm. I was pleased with the outcome of my case and I have to say if ever I need an Attorney I will definitely call them AGAIN! Thank you very much!

Lynesa Sweeting

Amazing staff! Courteous, professional, knowledgeable and always there for whatever you may need. I couldn't ask for better service. Thank you, thank you Shamis & Gentile, for working for me and thank you for caring for me as a person and not just a number. That's something that is hard to find nowadays!

Tiffany Finch-Wedding

Amazing staff! Courteous, professional, knowledgeable and always there for whatever you may need. I couldn't ask for better service. Thank you, thank you Shamis & Gentile, for working for me and thank you for caring for me as a person and not just a number. That's something that is hard to find nowadays!

Tiffany Finch-Wedding

Amazing staff! Courteous, professional, knowledgeable and always there for whatever you may need. I couldn't ask for better service. Thank you, thank you Shamis & Gentile, for working for me and thank you for caring for me as a person and not just a number. That's something that is hard to find nowadays!

Tiffany Finch-Wedding

Amazing staff! Courteous, professional, knowledgeable and always there for whatever you may need. I couldn't ask for better service. Thank you, thank you Shamis & Gentile, for working for me and thank you for caring for me as a person and not just a number. That's something that is hard to find nowadays!

Tiffany Finch-Wedding

Amazing staff! Courteous, professional, knowledgeable and always there for whatever you may need. I couldn't ask for better service. Thank you, thank you Shamis & Gentile, for working for me and thank you for caring for me as a person and not just a number. That's something that is hard to find nowadays!

Tiffany Finch-Wedding

Amazing staff! Courteous, professional, knowledgeable and always there for whatever you may need. I couldn't ask for better service. Thank you, thank you Shamis & Gentile, for working for me and thank you for caring for me as a person and not just a number. That's something that is hard to find nowadays!

Tiffany Finch-Wedding

Wonderful experience from beginning to end. My attorney was always keeping me up to date. I never had to chase for status. Great team. I highly recommend them.

Kelly Fulton

Amazing staff! Courteous, professional, knowledgeable and always there for whatever you may need. I couldn't ask for better service. Thank you, thank you Shamis & Gentile, for working for me and thank you for caring for me as a person and not just a number. That's something that is hard to find nowadays!

Tiffany Finch-Wedeking

I absolutely love Shamis & Gentile! The attorneys' attentiveness is remarkable, making me feel valued as a client. Their expertise and clear communication set them apart. The pay close attention to detail and ensure they follow-up with clients. I highly recommend Shamis & Gentile for anyone in need of outstanding legal representation.

Monica De Armas

what a great firm! Always available for any questions/concerns I had. Were very honest with me and always kept me in the loop. Highly recommend!

Daniel Mendoza

Andrew was extremely personable, timely with responding and keeping me abreast with the status of my case. I would highly recommend this firm. I was pleased with the outcome of my case and I have to say if ever I need an Attorney I will definitely call them AGAIN! Thank you very much!

Lynesa Sweeting

This Firm is amazing. It didn’t take that long to investigate and settle my claim. They got me a settlement for more than I expected. Awesome job everyone.

Tish Nelson

Great experience with the Shamis and Gentile team. Andrew always kept me informed on what was happening with my case and also gave me real expectations on what I could expect as an outcome, which he met! 10/10 would recommend to friends and family.

Manuel Fente

It was a pleasure working with Andrew and his work team! Not only a great attorney but a remarkable person to have on your side through your legal ordeal. I DEFINITELY RECOMMEND SHAMIS & GENTILE, PA!!!

Maggie F.

Really terrific law firm!!! I have worked with Shamis & Gentile on a number of cases, and have always felt connected to my attorneys no matter how many clients they may have. Excellent client services, great communication, and successful results! With Andrew Shamis’s representation, I have received thousands!

Daniel Getz

Shamis & Gentile Attorneys are the best in the area! I have worked with them for quite some time, and they have always settled my cases quickly and efficiently. I wouldn’t recommend anyone go elsewhere. Thank you Shamis & Gentile!!

Breanna B.

I had an above excellent relationship with them. They were very professional. Very responsive and took the time to inform me every step of the way.

Jason G.